Is MM the Enemy?
The Ghost in the Machine
In the folklore of trading forums and social media, the Market Maker (MM) is a shadowy, omnipotent villain. They are the boogeyman, the "they" in "They are hunting my stops." They are portrayed as a malevolent force with a personal vendetta against your account, manipulating prices at will to ensure your failure.
On the other end of the spectrum is the sterile, academic definition: "A Market Maker is a firm that provides liquidity and depth to markets by being willing to buy and sell securities at all times." In this view, they are benevolent public servants, the friendly grocer of the financial world.
Both of these views are dangerously wrong. They are childish caricatures of a complex and ruthless reality.
The Market Maker is not your friend. The Market Maker is not your enemy. The Market Maker is a hyper-efficient, profit-driven inventory management business. And you are not their customer. You are a data point in their inventory flow.
Understanding this distinction is the final step in moving from an amateur's conspiratorial mindset to a professional's operational one. The actions of the MM that feel like a personal attack are, in fact, the impersonal, logical, and highly predictable consequences of their business model. This chapter will pull back the curtain on that model. We will not teach you to fight the MM—that is a battle you will always lose. We will teach you to understand their business so profoundly that you can anticipate their next move and use their powerful current to your advantage.
Part 1: The Business of Market Making – A Low-Margin, High-Volume Enterprise
To understand the MM's actions, you must first understand their business. Their official mandate from the exchange is to provide a continuous two-sided market—meaning they must always be willing to post a price at which they will buy (the Bid) and a price at which they will sell (the Ask).
The Profit Engine: The Bid-Ask Spread
The MM's primary, low-risk profit comes from the tiny difference between the bid and the ask price, known as the spread. If the bid for a stock is $100.00 and the ask is $100.01, the MM can simultaneously buy from a seller at $100.00 and sell to a buyer at $100.01, instantly capturing a $0.01 profit. Multiplied by millions of shares per day, this becomes a massive, steady revenue stream. Their entire business is incentivized to encourage as many transactions as possible. More volume equals more spread capture.
The Great Risk: Unbalanced Inventory
The spread is the safe profit. The real danger to the MM is inventory.
Unlike a normal trader, an MM cannot always choose when to buy or sell. If a wave of retail traders suddenly decides to sell an asset, the MM, as the provider of liquidity, is often obligated to be the buyer on the other side.
When you sell, the MM buys. They are now long the asset and carrying inventory. They are exposed to the risk of the price falling.
When you buy, the MM sells. They are now short the asset. They are exposed to the risk of the price rising.
The MM's core objective is to get rid of this unwanted inventory and return to a "flat" or "delta-neutral" position as quickly as possible. The MM does not want to take a directional view on the market; they want to be a tollbooth operator. Their seemingly manipulative actions are almost always a direct result of their desperate need to manage the risk of their unbalanced inventory.
Part 2: "Manipulation" Unmasked – The MM's Risk Management is Your Trading Reality
Let's re-examine the most common trader complaints through the cold, logical lens of the MM's business model.
Case Study: The Stop Hunt as an Inventory Purge
The Amateur's View: "The MM saw my stop at $99.50 and came for me personally! It's a conspiracy!"
The Professional's View (The MM's Perspective):
The Imbalance: A positive news story comes out. Thousands of retail traders rush to buy the stock at $100. To facilitate these trades, the MM has had to sell to all of them. The MM is now holding a massive, unwanted short position. They are dangerously exposed; if the price continues to rise, their losses could be enormous.
The Problem: The MM needs to buy back shares to cover their short and get flat. But if they place a huge buy order, they will drive the price up, increasing their own losses. They need to find a large pool of forced, inelastic sellers.
The Solution: Their systems scan the order book and identify a giant cluster of retail sell-stop orders resting below the psychological support at $100—let's say at $99.50. This is the giant pool of forced selling they need.
The Action: The MM's trading algorithm initiates a short-term attack. It may place large sell offers on the book to scare away buyers or sell a small portion of another inventory to push the price down from $100 to $99.50.
The Result: The stop-loss cascade is triggered. The thousands of retail longs are forced to sell their positions. The MM's algorithm, which initiated the move, is now on the other side of those trades, quietly buying from all the panicked sellers. In a matter of seconds, they have covered their massive short position, their inventory risk is gone, and their books are flat. The price, no longer under artificial pressure, snaps back above $100.
The MM was not hunting you. They were hunting the massive pool of liquidity that you and everyone else conveniently placed for them. It was not an act of malice; it was a necessary act of risk management for their business.
The "Chart Painting" to Induce Liquidity
Sometimes, in a low-volume market, an MM needs to stimulate activity to earn their spread. They may "paint the chart" by moving the price back and forth between two well-defined levels. This creates the illusion of clean support and resistance, which encourages traders to place limit orders and stops at these predictable levels. This builds up the very liquidity pools that the MM can then use for their own inventory management needs. They are encouraging you to build the waterhole where they can later hunt.
Part 3: The MM's Footprints – How to See Their Game on the Chart
You can't see the MM's internal books, but you can see the footprints they leave on the chart.
The "Bart Simpson" Pattern: A sudden, sharp spike up (or down), followed by a flat, low-volume "churn," and then a sharp reversal back to where it started. This often represents an MM engineering a move to a liquidity pool (e.g., triggering stops above a high), transacting their business in the flat phase, and then removing their influence, allowing the price to return to its natural equilibrium.
The Absorption Spike: An unusually high volume candle with a very small body, often at a key support or resistance level. This can be a sign of an MM absorbing a massive wave of orders (e.g., absorbing all the panic selling at a low) without letting the price move much further. It is a sign of a massive inventory shift.
The Pre-Market/Post-Market Games: MMs often use the thin liquidity of pre-market or after-hours sessions to move the price to a key level (e.g., above yesterday's high or below yesterday's low) to trigger stops and set the "tone" for the main trading session before most retail participants can react.
Part 4: The Professional's Protocol – Trading with the "House"
Your goal is not to beat the MM. Your goal is to align your trades with the MM's business needs. You want to be on the same side as the house.
Never Be Obvious: This is the prime directive. If you place your stops at the same psychological round numbers and clean chart levels as everyone else, you are making yourself a willing and delicious part of the MM's inventory solution. Use volatility-based stops (ATR) or place them beyond the obvious "kill zone."
Anticipate the Inventory Rebalance: Think about the market's positioning. Has a stock been grinding higher all day on retail enthusiasm? If so, the MM is likely net short. The probability of a sharp, late-day "rug pull" to shake out some of those longs so the MM can cover their shorts before the close is very high. Understanding this prevents you from getting caught in these predictable moves.
Trade the Aftermath of the Hunt: The highest-probability setup is often not the hunt itself, but the reversal that comes immediately after. When you see a violent stop hunt below a key low, followed by a powerful reclaim of that level, it is a giant red flag that the MM has just finished accumulating a long position. Entering a long trade after this has happened is a trade that is aligned with the MM's now-long inventory. You are piggybacking on their move.
Respect Their Territory: MMs are most active and dominant during periods of low volume and range-bound chop. This is where they make their living from the spread. A professional trader often stands aside during these "MM-controlled" environments and waits for true, high-volume directional momentum to return, where the MM's influence is diminished by larger players.
Conclusion: The River Guide
Is the Market Maker the enemy? No.
The Market Maker is the river. It is a powerful, amoral force of nature that carves the landscape of the chart. It has a current, it has rapids, and it has deep, quiet pools. The amateur, unaware of its power, tries to swim directly against the current and inevitably drowns, blaming the river for their demise.
The professional does not fight the river. They become a master river guide. They study its flows, they understand where the current is strongest, they recognize the signs of a coming waterfall, and they respect its power. They use the river's own immense energy to navigate their small raft to their destination.
Stop seeing the Market Maker as your personal nemesis. Start seeing their actions as the most powerful, predictable, and logical force on your chart. Learn to read their inventory games, anticipate their risk management moves, and align your own strategy with their powerful current. Only then can you stop fighting the market and begin to flow with it.
Last updated